The Ultimate Philly Thing: Billy Penn’s bracket reaches the Sweet 16

You voted in Round 1 for what you think are some of the *most* Philly things. Now the stakes are higher, and the competition is stiffer.

most_philly_thing_32-round_02_v1
anna

Round 2 of voting has ended. Winners are listed below. 

Welcome to Round 2 of Billy Penn‘s pseudoscientific, made-up, but otherwise utterly reliable bracket-tournament-style contest crowning The Most Philly Thing Ever. We picked the most Philly things we could think of in four categories: the most Philly person, the most Philly food and drink, the most Philly thing from the outside and the most Philly pastime. You voted in Round 1 — now the stakes are higher, and the competition is stiffer.

We picked two competitors in each sub-category, and then seeded them. Round One had 16 match-ups for a total of 32 Philly things. Welcome to the Sweet 16, people. (Disagree with our seeding and selections? Send your angry tweets to @billy_penn and we may or may not argue back.)

As the Democratic union machine says, vote early and vote often.

Round 1 recap: Most Philly person

Best Founding Father: Ben Franklin and William (Billy) Penn

Chef’s Empire: Jose Garces and Stephen Starr

Most Hollywood: Will Smith and M. Night Shyamalan

Most Political: Chris Matthews and Ed Rendell

The round 2 match-ups:

2.franklinvssmith

Will Smith once owned the Philadelphia playgrounds where he chilled out, maxed and relaxed, but Ben Franklin helped bring Philadelphia and America the freedom of choice that is allowing you to choose whether Hitch or democracy is more important.

WINNER: Ben Franklin

2.rendellvsbillypenn

Ed Rendell helped remake the city in the ’90s. Ya know, the one that Billy Penn founded.

WINNER: Billy Penn

Most Philly food or drink

The competitors:

Most Philly Snack: TaskyKake and Soft Pretzel

Most Philly Sugary Sweet: Peanut Chews and Water Ice

Most Philly Beer: Yards Brawler and Kenzinger

Sammich-off: Cheesesteak and Roast Pork

The round 2 match-ups:

2.cheesesteakvswaterice

Philly cheesesteaks are an institution in their own rite, but wooder ice could pull an upset here.

WINNER: Cheesesteak

2.pretzelvstastykake

The Philly Soft Pretzel is up against our fave childhood snacks. TastyKake beat out Roast Pork in Round 1 — can it pull off another upset?

WINNER: Soft pretzel

Most Philly thing from the outside

The competitors:

-Adelphia pun: Filthadelphia and Killadelphia

Most Philly cliche (that’s really true): Rocky’s town and Awful sports fans

Most musical representation: “Summertime” and Motown Philly

Most Philly establishment: Wawa and Reading Terminal Market

The round 2 match-ups:

2.wawavsfilthadelphia

Wawa is ubiquitous, but Filthadelphia is just plain true.

WINNER: Wawa

2.sportsvsreading

Booing Santa Claus, holding cells, batteries, the list goes on for Awful sports fans. DiNic’s pork, Fourth Street Cookies and the Flying Monkey Bakery have Reading Terminal Market putting up a battle in this matchup.

WINNER: Reading Terminal Market

Most Philly pastime or activity

The competitors:

Best Baseball Team: Taney Dragons and Philadelphia Phillies

Best Basketball Team: Temple U. and Philadelphia 76ers

Best Drunken Party: Mummer’s Parade and Fat Tuesday on South Street

Best Parking Practice: Center lane parking and Saving parking spots

The round 2 match-ups:

2.philliesvsparking

Our nation’s oldest continuing sports pastime is the Phillies, but saving parking spots is that asshole-y thing we all hate to admit we do.

WINNER: Phillies

2.centerlanevsmummers

A lot of cities park in the center lane, but none like we do here. And no city has anything remotely close to the Mummers.

WINNER: Mummer’s Parade

Thanks for reading another Billy Penn story

Seems you’re the kind of person who really digs in. Want more? Sign up for our morning update, the quick, easy, free way to stay on top of Philly news.

Thanks for reading Billy Penn

Like the story above, everything we publish is powered by our members. If you enjoy reading, throw us a bone! Just $5/month makes more difference than you’d think.

Thanks for reading! We need you.

Member donations power our newsroom. If Billy Penn helps you feel more connected to Philly, we’d love to count you in. Will you join us?

Lock in your support

Reader support powers our newsroom. A monthly membership helps lock it in.

Can we count on you as a Billy Penn sustainer?

Winning the local journalism game

Thank you: Your support as a member is powering our news gathering.

Know someone else who might like our work? Invite them to join.