5 great Philly fried chicken sandwiches to eat instead of Popeye’s

Go taste the hot new offering, sure — then pivot to these local favorites.

sshp-credit-danyahenninger-fednuts-chickensandwich2
Danya Henninger / Billy Penn
danya

Popeye’s new fried chicken is being hailed as something transcendent. It’s set social media on fire, sparked thinkpieces from the New Yorker, and even brought out the Mike Scott Hive in full hungry force.

Granted, having a cheap and easy alternative to the ethically-questionable but tastiest-of-genre Chick-fil-A sandwich is a serious bonus.

But no matter how juicy the breast meat, how crispy the batter, how perfect the balance of roll-to-filling-to-sauce, one thing about the sandwich remains true: it’s from a chain. When you buy one, you’re padding the pockets of a Canadian multinational fast-food holding company.

Good news: there’s plenty of local alternatives that give the delicious-but-corporate sando a run for its money — if not beat it outright. Here are five fantastic, local, Southern-style fried chicken sandwiches to try instead of (or in addition to) Popeye’s.

Love & Honey

1100 N. Front St.

This husband-and-wife outfit often sells out despite its semi-hidden location beneath the highway in Northern Liberties. Like the whole birds on the menu, the “OG” fried chicken sandwich features meat that’s juicy from a long buttermilk brine. Top that with crunchy-spicy slaw and sweet pickle chips, layer on ranch dressing and slap the whole thing on a schmatz-toasted bun and you have something entirely worthy of its price. Also available: a mouth-searing Nashville hot version ($9).

Federal Donuts

Multiple locations

Originally introduced as a summertime-only offering, the fried chicken sandwich at the Cook and Solomonov donut shop has evolved into a beloved cult favorite. With a buttermilk ranch dusting sparking the twice-fried breast and a creamy dollop of rooster sauce complementing the slick American cheese and pickle crunch, this Martin’s Potato Roll vehicle is one of the essential between-bread options in Philadelphia ($8).

Redcrest 

1525 S. 11th St.

Opened on East Passyunk last year as a classical chef’s first foray into counter service, this poultry destination offers four different sandwich arrangements — all based around the more flavorful thigh instead of the usual breast. The incarnation most comparable to Popeye’s is the buttermilk, which sees long strips of pickle, thick garlic aioli and cooling lettuce shreds fit inside a cocoon of soft roll ($8).

FreeByrd

111 S. Independence Mall E.

Inside the Bourse Food Hall is the first outpost of this new brand from the chef-partner duo behind a pub mini-chain with nine locations along the East Coast. The fried chicken sandwich has been winning raves since launch, with many calling it equivalent it to the Chick-fil-A gold standard — albeit at double the cost. The locally-sourced breast is crisped up in the fryer, then slathered with Alabama white BBQ sauce and served in a pillowy bun with a few pickles for crunch ($10).

Prohibition Taproom

501 N. 13th St.

When you have time to sit down, this tavern holding down the corner of 13th and Spring Garden offers a solid Southern-style contender. The birds here are pickle-brined, which makes meat extra tender. The crackling skin gets set off by the tang of pickled green tomato, then gussied up with sweet beer mustard dressing. Add the ooze of pepper jack and throw it all on a brioche bun, complete with fries for a cool $12.

Thanks for reading another Billy Penn story

Seems you’re the kind of person who really digs in. Want more? Sign up for our free morning newsletter, the easy way to stay on top of Philly news.

Thanks for reading Billy Penn

Like the story above, everything we publish is powered by our members. If you enjoy reading, join today: Just $5/month makes more difference than you’d think.

Thanks for reading! We need you.

Reader donations power our newsroom. If Billy Penn helps you feel more connected to Philly, we’d love to count you as a member. Will you join us?

Lock in your support

Reader support powers our newsroom. A monthly membership helps lock it in.

Can we count on you as a Billy Penn sustainer?

Winning the local journalism game

Thank you: Member support powers our newsroom.

Know someone else who might like our work? Invite them to sign up for our free morning newsletter.