💌 Love Philly? So do we. Let’s be friends. Sign up for the Billy Penn newsletter today.
An emotional crowd of Academy of Natural Sciences supporters filled Philadelphia City Council chambers Monday as lawmakers pressed university and city officials about the museum’s closure and what it would take to reopen.
Drexel University President Antonio Merlo, subpoenaed after missing an October Council hearing, testified that academy leadership had considered closing the museum and relocating its collection of more than 19 million specimens to Cleveland or Abu Dhabi. Merlo said Drexel opposed the proposal, which never moved forward.
The hearing also brought renewed discussion of funding. Council members expressed interest in providing recurring financial support, potentially before the end of the year. Drexel officials estimated the museum needs roughly $5 million annually to cover its operating shortfall, plus tens of millions more for building repairs.
The Save the Academy Coalition, which has organized demonstrations since the museum closed, expressed optimism about the hearing.
“I’ll be honest, I’m personally most looking forward to the party we’ll throw when that museum opens again to the public,” wrote Save the Academy organizer Sara McAnulty to Billy Penn. “I am now confident that as a city we will be able to make that happen.”
The museum on the Benjamin Franklin Parkway closed Sept. 27 amid mounting financial pressures. Monday’s hearing was the second held by Council’s Committee on Legislative Oversight, which is investigating the closure and possible paths to reopening. Supporters carrying signs applauded Council members who pressed officials for answers and occasionally booed testimony.
Deputy mayor faces questions over city’s involvement
Deputy Mayor for Strategic Initiatives Patricia “Trish” Wellenbach was the first to testify Monday. She apologized for missing the Oct. 26 hearing and said her absence was not intended as disrespect toward Council.
Wellenbach repeatedly emphasized her limited authority. Appointed as an interim senior adviser to the academy in September, she said her role was to support leadership during the transition, not determine whether the museum should reopen.
“I believe it is vitally important that we determine a path forward to continue to have a public-facing experience that opens the hearts and minds of wonder to the natural world, to children and adults,” Wellenbach said. “I believe that we will find that path forward. I believe it may take us a little bit longer to get there than some of us would like.”
Councilmember Jeffery Young Jr., whose district includes the museum, asked who could explain the closure and move reopening discussions forward. Wellenbach referred those questions to Drexel and academy leadership.
Councilmember Rue Landau also questioned whether Mayor Cherelle Parker’s administration had committed funding.
Wellenbach said she was aware of estimates that operating the museum would require approximately $5 million annually but could not provide a breakdown. She also said the administration had not discussed providing funding.
That answer drew boos from the audience.
Councilmember Isaiah Thomas, who chairs the committee, said lawmakers wanted to explore providing recurring financial support over three to five years, potentially through legislation before the end of December.
No amount has been formally proposed, and it remains unclear whether Parker would support the funding. Lawmakers would need to move quickly to approve funding before the year’s end.
Drexel president details failed negotiations
Merlo followed Wellenbach, appearing alongside Drexel Chief Financial Officer Helen Bowman and university counsel Anne Loftus.
He began by apologizing for missing the previous hearing, explaining that he had remained on campus during a university accreditation visit.
Merlo said Drexel had provided approximately $49 million in direct financial support and another $46 million in services and contributions since affiliating with the academy in 2011.
He said a September 2025 academy board retreat exposed significant differences over the institution’s future.
“The academy board and executive leadership presented the closure of the public museum as unpreventable and inevitable,” Merlo said. “They also proposed a plan to relocate the academy’s entire collection of specimens either to Cleveland or Abu Dhabi.”
Merlo said Drexel opposed removing the collections from Philadelphia and proposed an alternative that would keep them under university stewardship, with public exhibitions potentially held outside the Parkway building.
That alternative, however, also contemplated closing the existing museum and potentially selling the property.
The institutions later entered negotiations involving former U.S. Ambassador to Canada David L. Cohen, whom Gov. Josh Shapiro asked to help broker an agreement.
Merlo said the parties reached preliminary terms in September, but the academy’s trustees ultimately declined to approve a final agreement.
Heated questioning and the cost of reopening
Questioning became tense when Thomas challenged Merlo over his limited engagement with City Council and why lawmakers needed to subpoena him.
Thomas criticized the university president for not seeking assistance before the museum closed. Merlo acknowledged that Drexel should have contacted Council earlier and apologized for the communication failures.
“This might be your welcome to Philadelphia moment. I don’t know, but in this city, it can’t work like this,” Thomas said. “We don’t work like this. We don’t move like this.”
Merlo confirmed that the decision to close the public museum had been made jointly by Drexel and academy leadership. He said both institutions would also need to agree on reopening.
Bowman provided additional details about the financial challenges. She said fiscal year 2026 audited statements showed approximately $6.6 million in museum operating expenses and $2 million in revenue, producing an annual deficit of $4.6 million.
Merlo said reopening would also require substantial spending on repairs to the Parkway building, potentially costing tens of millions of dollars beyond annual operating support.
The university has agreed to participate in a foundation-funded feasibility study examining the academy’s finances, facilities and potential operating models. The review could take up to 12 months.

A possible split between Drexel and the academy
The hearing also highlighted the increasingly likely possibility that Drexel and the academy could end their 15-year affiliation.
Merlo said Drexel would be willing to let the academy become independent but that the institutions remain divided over financial terms.
According to Merlo, academy trustees requested five years of continued financial and administrative support, along with funding to cover the costs of separating.
Drexel was willing to provide temporary administrative services but not continue cash support, he said.
Academy board chair Suzanne Biemiller, who attended Monday’s hearing without prepared remarks, has disputed Drexel’s characterization of the negotiations. Notably, Biemiller said the academy’s future was not discussed during the board retreat in which Merlo said academy leadership proposed a plan to close the museum.
“What was presented to the board in September of 2025 at the retreat was really only an examination of the collections and the science itself,” said Biemiller. “The museum was not part of that discussion that day.”
She previously told The Inquirer that ending Drexel’s funding immediately would threaten the institution’s survival and that any separation would need to happen gradually.
Biemiller also testified Monday that academy trustees had notified officials in Parker’s and Shapiro’s administrations in late 2025 that Drexel was seeking to renegotiate its financial support.
The two institutions have not reached an agreement on separation, leaving the museum’s future unresolved.
Supporters call for reopening
Members of the public also testified Monday, continuing the advocacy that has surrounded the academy since its closure.
The Save the Academy Coalition thanked Council for establishing a public record of the decisions that led to the closure and urged officials to act while the independent review proceeds.
“It is time to set a date for reopening the museum as the independent assessment proceeds alongside the City’s taskforce,” the coalition wrote to Billy Penn in a statement after the hearing.
For now, the museum remains closed, with its potential reopening dependent on resolving the financial and governance questions that have divided Drexel and academy leadership.





