💌 Love Philly? So do we. Let’s be friends. Sign up for the Billy Penn newsletter today.


Martina White’s first victory in Northeast Philadelphia came with some unusual help for a Republican: feuding Democrats and labor unions willing to cross party lines.

Eleven years later, the unions are still with her. Democrats still outnumber Republicans among registered voters in the 170th House District. And White is still winning — amid a historic “blue wave” of Democratic victories and even when the district votes Democratic in other races.

In this month’s midterm elections, Gov. Josh Shapiro won White’s district by roughly 23 percentage points as Democrats secured the state house and senate in Pennsylvania. With the same votes, White won another term by about 15, defeating Democrat Rob Gurtcheff.

White, now 38, is Philadelphia’s only Republican state representative and chair of the House Republican Caucus. Her latest victory came as Democrats expanded their state House majority and took control of the state Senate.

“I think that the people here, they vote for the person that they trust, not a party label,” White told Billy Penn.

That trust has endured alongside a record that includes challenges to Philadelphia’s immigration policies and support for questioning Pennsylvania’s certified 2020 presidential election results. 

“I think that people know me for me,” said White. “I think that it’s important that people know where I stand on the issues.”

A district that crosses party lines

White was a 26-year-old financial adviser when she won the March 2015 special election to replace Democrat Brendan Boyle, who had left for Congress. Democrats held a roughly 2-to-1 registration advantage. But the party was split over Boyle’s successor.

Boyle supported one prospective nominee; local Democratic leaders chose Sarah Del Ricci, whose husband was a ward leader with ties to then-Lt. Gov. Mike Stack. Some unions, unhappy with the selection and their relationships with Stack, backed White. The Fraternal Order of Police Lodge 5 was among the organizations that helped knock on doors and turn out voters for her.

White won with about 57% of the vote and became the first new Republican elected to the Pennsylvania House from Philadelphia in 25 years.

She won again against Democratic opponents in 2016, 2018 and 2020, then faced no Democratic challenger in 2022 or 2024. During her tenure, the Far Northeast has grown more diverse, including Russian-speaking and South Asian communities alongside longstanding working-class neighborhoods.

Northeast residents will tell you voter registration has never told the entire story of the area. Donald Trump carried the 170th by about 15 points in 2024 despite the Democratic registration advantage. Two years later, Shapiro won it by a larger margin than Trump had, while White also won comfortably.

“You do have crossover voting to Republicans, and actually vice versa,” said Andrew McGinley of the nonpartisan Committee of Seventy, who grew up in Northeast Philadelphia.

State Sen. Joe Picozzi, a Republican elected in 2024 whose district includes White’s, said he meets Northeast residents who vote for one party almost everywhere except particular local races.

“That’s just how the Northeast is,” Picozzi said.

Familiar faces, state dollars

White points to her district office as central to her work, where staff helps constituents seek benefits, navigate state agencies and connect families with services. She says they don’t ask residents about their party affiliation before providing support.

That attention is familiar to Judith Dotzman, president and CEO of SPIN, a nonprofit founded in Northeast Philadelphia that serves children and adults with intellectual disabilities and autism.

White has attended SPIN events, met with families and referred constituents to the organization for services, Dotzman said. At its fall festival in October, White and her staff distributed information and spoke with families, according to Dotzman.

“She has been a champion of services for people with intellectual disability and autism,” Dotzman said. “She is extremely connected to families in her district.”

In September, White and Picozzi announced a $917,450 state grant for emergency generators at SPIN’s community center and 24 residential homes. Those homes serve residents who may be difficult to relocate during a power outage.

SPIN is nonpartisan, and Dotzman said it maintains relationships with Democrats as well as Republicans. The organization contacts newly elected lawmakers to explain its services; it did the same when White took office.

Still, such relationships keep White in contact with residents and with organizations that depend on state decisions. Chair of the House Republican Caucus in Harrisburg, White is familiar with how to navigate legislation and funding matters.

“Being a state representative who’s available to people, who’s seen as part of the community, public about the work that they’re doing, all of those things are very effective,” McGinley said.

White cited her support for educational tax-credit scholarships, which help families pay for private-school alternatives, and her work with Democratic state Rep. Christina Sappey on the Working Pennsylvanians Tax Credit. The latter provides qualifying low-income workers with a refundable state tax credit.

The school scholarship approach remains contested: Supporters emphasize parental choice, while critics question the use of tax incentives for private education amid public school funding needs.

While labor unions traditionally stand with Democrats, Pennsylvania’s state Rep. Martina White has earned their continued support and gone against her own Republican Party to sustain that support. (Courtesy of state Rep. Martina White)

Labor remains with White

One of the more unusual parts of White’s coalition is how little some of it has changed since 2015. The Pennsylvania AFL-CIO endorsed her this year, along with unions representing construction workers and first responders. FOP Lodge 5 remains firmly behind her. 

“Rep. Martina White has earned our endorsement for her unwavering support of our members since her first campaign in 2015,” the lodge said in a written statement. “She has continually showed up for us in Harrisburg and in Philadelphia and we will always have her back.”

White said she was “honored” to receive the continued support of the lodge and local unions as well as other endorsers.

AFT Pennsylvania backed White’s opponent Gurtcheff, as did other labor and progressive organizations. But White said unions supporting her knocked on doors for her before the election and on Election Day.

The relationship has occasionally put her at odds with conservatives. In October, Americans for Prosperity withdrew its endorsement after White supported legislation expanding prevailing-wage protections to certain workers involved in publicly funded construction projects. The conservative group said the measure would raise taxpayer costs. White said it protected skilled workers’ wages, including those of people in her district. Shapiro signed the measure after it passed with bipartisan support.

Picozzi, who has cultivated similar union ties, sees that position as part of a longstanding southeastern Pennsylvania Republican tradition.

“We’re Republicans, we believe in a degree of fiscal responsibility, but we also support organized labor,” he said.

For Democrats, those relationships present a practical problem. Unions that might otherwise supply volunteers, money and trusted messengers to a Democratic challenger have instead spent years supporting the incumbent Republican.

An uphill fight and a choice about where to spend

Michael Doyle Jr. knows how hard it is to run against White. He challenged her in 2018 and 2020 and lost both times, by double-digit margins.

Doyle blames weak Democratic organizing and a failure to work with labor for the party’s lack of electoral success in the area. 

“Until labor and Democrats get together and organize up in this district,” Doyle said, “Republicans will continue to represent it.”

White had no Democratic opponent in either of the previous two general elections.

There have also been questions about whether party leaders had much interest in contesting her seat. In 2024, Billy Penn reported that two Democratic insiders described an informal understanding between the city’s two major parties: Republicans would not seriously challenge Democratic state Sen. Jimmy Dillon, while Democrats would not mount a major campaign against White. The purported understanding was never established as a formal deal.

Picozzi challenged Dillon anyway, without the Philadelphia Republican Party’s endorsement, and won with support from state Senate Republicans. His campaign reported knocking on roughly 70,000 doors.

This year’s race for White’s seat was different. Gurtcheff, an Army veteran and fraud investigator, had Shapiro’s endorsement, support from Democratic and progressive organizations and a campaign that reported knocking its 10,000th door in September — an effort White acknowledged.

“The grassroots organization that took place during this last election was more significant than I have seen in years past,” she said. “It was a significant effort that was put forward against me, and I take every election seriously or every opponent seriously because I feel strongly that my constituents deserve the best.”

The Pennsylvania House Democratic Campaign Committee said it funded campaign staff and provided other assistance. Its communications director, Sydney Robinson, called Gurtcheff the first strong challenge to White in recent memory and praised his work.

But White had a considerable financial advantage. Campaign finance figures compiled by PoliticsPA through June 8 showed White had raised about $254,000, compared with roughly $11,400 for Gurtcheff. Those figures are of course not final campaign totals and do not include all outside spending.

The HDCC did not specify how much it invested in Gurtcheff. 

“As a statewide organization, we must make difficult decisions to invest strategically based on all of the available data,” Robinson said.

“We fully believe that a seat like the 170th is flippable,” she added.

McGinley said a popular incumbent makes such decisions harder: Parties with finite resources may see more promising places to spend than a seat they have repeatedly lost.

White a moderate, by her definition

White calls herself a moderate Republican. Her record offers what may be a more complicated picture.

In December 2020, White joined Republican lawmakers asking members of Congress to challenge Pennsylvania’s electoral votes for Joe Biden. The state had certified Biden’s victory, and efforts to overturn the result failed to establish fraud sufficient to change it.

White still stands by signing the letter. When asked about it, she pointed to concerns about election procedures after Pennsylvania expanded mail voting.

“People want to be able to trust their elections and that there’s integrity and that there are reliable results,” she said.

She said the letter had not damaged her relationship with constituents.

Notably, White has repeatedly opposed Philadelphia’s sanctuary-city policies, including sponsoring 2017 legislation that would have withheld certain state funds from municipalities limiting cooperation with federal immigration authorities. The proposal also would have allowed some crime victims to sue those municipalities. White described it as a public safety measure; opponents warned about its effect on city services and immigrant communities.

She has also been an outspoken critic of Philadelphia District Attorney Larry Krasner. 

In 2022, White proposed limiting the city’s district attorney to two terms and helped lead the Republican effort to impeach Krasner that year. As recently as September, White called for his resignation.

But the city’s crime numbers complicate the argument that Philadelphia has become increasingly dangerous under Krasner. After reaching a record 562 homicides in 2021, the city recorded 222 in 2025, its lowest total since 1966. Homicides have continued declining in 2026, along with overall violent crime, according to Philadelphia police data. Those citywide figures do not precisely reflect conditions in individual Northeast neighborhoods.

Philadelphia District Attorney Larry Krasner defends the policies of his first two terms at a candidate forum at WHYY on April 22, 2025. (Kimberly Paynter/WHYY)

Picozzi said White’s criticism of Krasner reflects residents’ concerns about public safety in the Northeast.

“I think the Northeast is primarily, first and foremost, concerned about public safety,” said Picozzi. “People are reporting the crimes down, but in the Northeast, things have gotten worse.”

Doyle, who challenged White twice, said he believes Krasner has become a powerful political target in the district, regardless of what crime statistics show. He said years of messaging about the district attorney have left voters fearful of his policies.

“They’ve been sold this false boogeyman persona, whether it was me running or Krasner or whoever, it’s the politics of fear,” said Doyle. “The messaging of fear and be afraid.”

Asked about her relationship with Trump and the MAGA movement today, White emphasized the district over national politics.

“I consider myself to be a moderate Republican, someone who is all common sense, with a very local approach,” she said. “As for national movements, I don’t relate because I’m very much locally focused.”

White acknowledged that a backlash against Trump hurt Republicans in the midterms. Some voters at polling places told her they were there to send a message to the president, she said.

“The president wasn’t on the ballot, but he was,” White said.

A model, with limits

Picozzi says he studied White’s campaigns before his own successful Senate run in 2024. Since taking office, he and White have worked together on local grants and appeared at civic meetings across their overlapping districts.

“I love working with Martina,” he said. “She’s got a decade of experience in public life over me, so I definitely try to take notes and learn a lot of things.”

Picozzi said he wants Republicans to put more emphasis on affordable housing, jobs, education, public safety and the daily cost of living.

“What we’re doing is the model for the future of the party,” he said.

White made a similar argument after her victory.

“The future of our party definitely looks a lot like Northeast Philadelphia,” she said.

It is a model with some difficult-to-copy features: a district with a history of electing Republicans, unions that sided with White at the beginning and never left, an established constituent-service operation and a Democratic opposition that has struggled to match her organization.

White now returns to Harrisburg as a Republican leader in a legislature controlled by Democrats. In the Far Northeast, the party that holds the voter registration advantage is still looking for the organization — and the candidate — to beat her.

Davis Cuffe is a general assignment reporter for Billy Penn. A North Carolina native, he graduated from UNC Charlotte in 2026 and joined WHYY that fall. Davis is a former WHYY intern and has worked...