💌 Love Philly? So do we. Let’s be friends. Sign up for the Billy Penn newsletter today.
Which of these three potential layouts do you think would work best for Philadelphia’s eventual permanent intercity bus terminal?
That’s the question that the city’s Department of Planning and Development is collecting more feedback on, at BusStation@phila.gov. Your responses will be added to the dozens of post-its and comments shared at the latest public meeting hosted by the city Nov. 4.
During the first round of site evaluations in February, possible sites were narrowed down to three options, and nearly 1,800 people gave feedback via a survey and in-person meetings.

That feedback led to updated layouts — which the planning department “want(s) to hear how those station locations and schematics affect you personally and what should we consider as we proceed down this planning path,” said Bruce Bohri, PR specialist with the agency.

30th and Arch streets
Located on a parking lot at 2931 Arch St., immediately north of 30th Street Station and adjacent to the Cira Centre office tower, this site is owned by Amtrak and is currently a favorite amongst Philadelphians giving public feedback.
“I always check Amtrak and the bus and oftentimes the bus is cheaper, but I still pay the premium for Amtrak because it’s just more convenient — I can get on the subway, I can go right to 30th Street Station and it’s more comfortable of an experience,” said Fishtown resident Evan Thalheimer. “It would be great to see a bus station elevated to the same level as something akin to the 30th Street Station.”
Thalheimer, who went to school at Drexel for architecture, attended the Nov. 4 public meeting to get a closer look at the proposed layouts and came away in favor of the 30th Street rendering. Why? Even without his preference for that location, “it’s the best bus station (layout),” he said.
“With the 30th Street Station one, anytime someone is entering the city – whether by the Northeast Corridor or by a bus, whichever one is cheaper – it’s always the same arrival experience,” Thalheimer said. “You’re arriving to the same part of the city, you know how to get to the subway. It’s one less barrier to come to Philadelphia or leave Philadelphia. It’s much more user-friendly than any of the other options.”

While this location is popular with many, it is also a high-traffic area with multiple highways and streets intersecting.
Bella Vista resident Nancy Biller said she understands the advantages of 30th Street — “more capacity, and access directly to Regional Rail and transport” — but said the grid of Market, Arch, and 29th and 30th streets is very busy with traffic, “kind of yucky,” and not particularly welcoming for people arriving in the city.

15th and Vine streets
This proposed site is currently a Philadelphia Gateway garage and an adjoining parking lot at 1500-1598 Vine St., owned by PennDOT and the Philadelphia Parking Authority.
Post-its left on the 15th/Vine feedback board listed pros as “most central location” but cons as having a “confusing layout.”

“The location on Vine Street, the bay is split into two sections with two separate waiting rooms and I think it’s gonna be a wayfinding nightmare,” said Thalheimer. “Imagine saying your bus is in Bay 16 and you go down into the waiting room and it’s buses 1 through 8, you’re like ‘where is 16?’ You have to go back up, go around, you’re confused, you’re late for your bus, all these things.”

8th and Arch streets
This option is the closest to the city’s current bus station at 8th and Filbert, which they currently are leasing for 10 years, until 2036.
The proposed site would sit on a pair of parking lots at 701-709 Arch St. and 721-737 Arch St., near 8th Street, which are next to the African American Museum. The properties are owned by the city and Parkway Corp.
Biller said she is a fan of this option for its proximity to “Chinatown, you’ve got Reading Terminal, you’ve got the Liberty Bell a few steps away.”
But for others, that proximity could also be a complication.

Challenges include coordinating with the museum, the impact on the nearby Federal Detention Center and other federal facilities, and the mixed ownership by the city and Parkway Corp. In addition, like the Filbert Street station, it would require routing buses near Chinatown, which could draw neighborhood opposition.
Next steps
According to Mason Austin, director of transportation and planning at the City Planning Commission, the 30th Street option “by far received the most positive response” during Phase 1 of feedback.
“One thing we weren’t necessarily expecting to hear (that) 90% of people boarding buses travel there by public transit or bicycling or walking — they are much less dependent on cars. We expect that an even more centrally located station would be even better utilized by people accessing via public transit.”
That meant that “being close to transit was by far the most important thing for people,” followed by amenities and “comfort – waiting areas, restrooms and knowing when the bus is gonna be coming.”

According to the city’s Department of Planning and Development, initial takeaways are:
- Travel to bus stops: Nearly 89% of respondents reported that they usually take transit, walk or bike to arrive at intercity bus stops/stations in Philadelphia. Only 38% reported driving or taking a taxi or car share.
- Preferred location: 30th and Arch received the most votes (65%) as the favorite among the three locations.
- Trip purpose: Vacation followed by visiting family were the top reasons for respondents’ most recent intercity bus trips.
- Station concerns: Proximity to other transportation options was, on average, the top concern, followed by public safety and security.
Asked how much influence state or p ownership will have on planning and decisions would have compared to user feedback, Austin noted that the one at 15th and Vine is state-owned, the one at 8th and Arch is mixed ownership 60% by the city and 40% in private ownership, and Amtrak owns 30th Street Station, technically a private corporation that’s government-related.
“So yes, they would have to be involved and be an active participant, but they are not involved right now,” he said.

Anticipating eventual need for state funding and support — and knowing that the 15th and Arch location is near his district — state Sen. Sharif Street’s legislative director Jawad Pullin also attended the November public meeting to see the proposed locations.
“For Sharif, it’s a combination for him of being a member of the Senate Appropriations Committee, someone who is interested in transportation and someone who has a vested interest in bringing money back to Philadelphia. Whichever one of these projects is done is going to need state and federal funds in order to make it happen,” Pullin said.
“The senator represents a very large contingency of public transit users all across North Philadelphia. Public transit is a core importance for him – making sure it’s safe, reliable and funded, which is the key thing, given that he is at the state level. So figuring out a fair funding formula for SEPTA has been a critical thing that he’s wanted to fight for,” he said.
There will be no third public meeting — the city’s final report will be released early next year, after which the city planning department will shift into the more technical phase of planning: financials, engineering feasibility and other issues.





