Photos: Fishtown’s St. Laurentius Church wins historic designation

Samuel Lieberman

Jul. 10, 2015, 3:22 p.m.

Fishtown’s St. Laurentius church just landed a spot on Philadelphia’s historic register. The building at 1600-1608 E. Berks St. will remain standing for now, despite plans by the Archdiocese of Philadelphia to demolish it. The decision by the Historical Commission closes one chapter in the neighborhood’s ongoing fight to save the church.

Friday’s meeting was the last hearing necessary for historic preservation, but if the diocese can prove that the restoration and repairs of the building are a significant financial burden, or if the Department of Licenses & Inspections finds that the building is a public safety hazard, this designation may not mean very much.

For now, the parishioners of St. Laurentius are elated:

St. Laurentius is the first Polish Catholic Church in Philadelphia. It was built around 1890 and designed by legendary ecclesiastic architect Edwin Forrest Durang.

There was no question among supporters that the church would be designated. Its historical and architectural significance has brought a dedicated crowd to the hearings that’s whooped and hollered, sneered and occasionally catcalled during meetings.

Oscar Beisert, 33, is an architectural historian who wrote the designation application for the people of St. Laurentius. “I am in the business of representing buildings that I call ‘friendless,'” he said. “This building is not only significant historically, it is significant now to this community.”

Last year, St. Laurentius was merged with the nearby Holy Name of Jesus Parish. The parishioners of St. Laurentius overwhelmingly refuse to attend mass at that location.

Representatives from the archdiocese and Holy Name of Jesus Parish have made the argument that historic designation represents a significant financial burden for the diocese, and had to be repeatedly reminded during the hearing that the purpose of Friday’s meeting was to determine only the historical significance of the building. In fact, it is not uncommon for the committee to designate buildings that are falling apart. A committee member stated that they have even nominated buildings in that past that were considered “imminent dangers.”

Even though most agreed that the likelihood of St. Laurentius becoming a functioning church again is slim, seeing the city dub the building important brought many tears to the crowd of onlookers.

Father John Sibel of Holy Name of Jesus Parish argued that the money that the parish was going to lose if the building was designated historic would be enough to jeopardize their other operations (like St. Laurentius School.)

The discussion trended toward theoretical at times about what Philadelphia should consider as boosting its character. Is it cultural heritage and old buildings, or is the character of Philadelphia a display of economic success, new development a other signs of growth?

Oscar Beisert, 33, has noticed a lack of preservation in Philadelphia even though it is one of the most historically rich cities in the country. He has been fighting for St. Laurentius because he sees a rare community in strong support of saving it.

When the meeting ended the crowd streamed out praising God, praising the city, and turning a conscious blind eye to the oncoming hurdles in their struggle to save their church.

MOVE victim remains

Three decades ago, Philly’s medical examiner sent 26 human brains to a Penn professor without consent

Despite vows to implement new policies, little appears to have been reformed.

A mural in honor of Dominique Rem'mie Fells at Graffiti Pier, created by artist Jeannine Kayembe-Oro

Friends and family honor the life of Dominique Rem’mie Fells with a big West Philly block party

Instead of a vigil, this year’s event is a celebration.

Headlines of Yore

The Phillies pitcher who married a movie star’s daughter and was nominated for a Pulitzer

Born in 1942, Larry Colton had a fascinating life.

Health care workers at the Temple University vaccination clinic in April 2021

Philly’s coronavirus response

How vaccination rate in Philly varies by race/ethnicity and age

Case counts in Philadelphia more than tripled over the latter half of July — and 99% are in people who haven't gotten both doses of the vaccine.

Philly food and drink scene

Best pizza in Philly? Tyrese Maxey picks Giovani’s in Center City

The rising Sixers star gave the underrated sports bar a shoutout on Instagram.

Left: Laura Foreman doing her job; Right: Convicted state legislator Henry 'Buddy' Cianfrani speaking to the media about their relationship

The story of Laura Foreman, reporter whose affair inspired The Inquirer’s ethics policy and proved a double standard in journalism

“I don’t care if my reporters are sleeping with elephants, as long as they aren’t covering the circus.”

Mayor Jim Kenney speaks at the opening of the FEMA clinic in March

Philly’s coronavirus response

Philadelphia: Still no vaccine requirements for city workers, same with SEPTA and school district

The Kenney administration continues to avoid a mandate.

Terrill Haigler aka Ya Fav Trashman led a protest on the steps of Philadelphia’s Municipal Services Building demanding clean streets, better pay for sanitation workers and the resignation of Streets Department Commissioner Carlton Williams. (Kimberly Paynter/WHYY)

Ya Fav Trashman and partners dump litter at Mayor Kenney’s feet to highlight city trash failures

The former sanitation worker is calling for the Streets Commissioner to resign, and also launching a cleanup app called Glitter.

Property owners are selling the building where Paradigm has been located for the past six years

Paradigm Gallery in bidding war for Queen Village home before someone else scoops it up

Support has been pouring in for the community mainstay, which has been in the neighborhood for a decade.

Crabfries and cheese sauce at Yankee Stadium in July

It’s true, Philly sports fan favorite Crabfries are now sold at Yankee Stadium

Chickie’s & Pete’s opened the Bronx ballpark concession stand this spring after two years in talks.

Headlines of Yore

One century ago, Philadelphia was ground zero in the battle to define free speech

As World War I raged, the local Socialist Party came under fire — and sparked a challenge to the Espionage Act.

1,000-year storm? In 1982, Northeast Philly saw even more intense rainfall than last week

“Thousand-year” means a weather event has a 0.1% chance of occurring annually — but with climate change, flood frequency is growing.

Lisa Phillips with her rescue dogs Charlie and Daisy. While on walks she searches out money on the street and collects it for charity.

Broke in Philly

Picking up pennies on Philly streets, and turning them into philanthropy

Lisa Phillips uses her knack for finding loose change to help wipe out medical debt.

An anti-violence rally in March 2021 at Philadelphia City Hall

Would a gun violence emergency help Philadelphia? Advocates just want action, whatever you call it

Semantics aside, the city still hasn’t set a timeline for distributing its new anti-violence grants.

Part of the group forming the new organization (L - R): Maso Kibble, Diamond Anthony, Jessica Kallup, Manny Frank-Lampon, Rich Frank-Lampon, André Henson aka Alzei Barbei Mizrahi, Elicia Gonzales, Jamaal Henderson, Abdul-Aliy Muhammad

Reinventing Philly’s Pride Parade: What happens next?

A new group is working to create a celebration that’s affordable, representative, and inclusive — without police.

Participants of the youth advocacy programs at Philadelphia's Juvenile Law Center pose at the Pa. State Capitol with program managers Cathy Moffa (L) and Marcía Hopkins (R)

Broke in Philly

Thousands of Philly foster youth are still waiting for pandemic relief money

The $1.1 million in federal funding is being distributed via $200 gift cards.

Cars will return to MLK Drive early August, with slimmed down traffic pattern

The Fairmount Park roadway is reopening to auto traffic after 16 months.

Users upset as costs force Free Library to drop free movie streaming service

Kanopy and Hoopla funds will be redirected to physical branches.

Philly food and drink scene

Three popular Philly bars are closing for a week to give workers paid vacation

Standard Tap, Johnny Brenda’s and The International join a small list of independent restaurants where staff get summer PTO.

Henderson made an appearance in the 1957 movie 'Jamboree' alongside Dick Clark

Headlines of Yore

35 years before ‘Hamilton,’ this legendary DJ was using rap to teach history in Philly middle schools

The "Ace from Outer Space" worked locally at WDAS — when he wasn't cutting records, running for office, or helping educate kids.

More Billy Penn

St. Laurentius is the first Polish Catholic Church in Philadelphia. It was built around 1890 and designed by legendary ecclesiastic architect Edwin Forrest Durang.

Last year, St. Laurentius was merged with the nearby Holy Name of Jesus Parish. The parishioners of St. Laurentius overwhelmingly refuse to attend mass at that location.

Even though most agreed that the likelihood of St. Laurentius becoming a functioning church again is slim, seeing the city dub the building important brought many tears to the crowd of onlookers.

Father John Sibel of Holy Name of Jesus Parish argued that the money that the parish was going to lose if the building was designated historic would be enough to jeopardize their other operations (like St. Laurentius School.)

Oscar Beisert, 33, has noticed a lack of preservation in Philadelphia even though it is one of the most historically rich cities in the country. He has been fighting for St. Laurentius because he sees a rare community in strong support of saving it.

When the meeting ended the crowd streamed out praising God, praising the city, and turning a conscious blind eye to the oncoming hurdles in their struggle to save their church.