Taste Philly’s best vegan cheesesteaks with the owner of Pat’s King of Steaks

There’s more contenders than ever in the annual plant-based sandwich battle.

Vegan cheesesteak from previous contest winner Blackbird Pizzeria

Vegan cheesesteak from previous contest winner Blackbird Pizzeria

Instagram / @floralhairvegan

If you want your cheesesteak to win this competition, it better pack plenty of deliciousness in its long hoagie roll. What it better not have? Actual cheese — or any meat.

The first time Vance Lehmkuhl held a contest to find Philly’s best vegan cheesesteak, he could easily rattle off all the potential competitors. But that was in 2014. Ask him who’ll contend in the event’s sixth annual edition this spring and it’s a different story.

“I know there are more now — I just don’t know exactly how many or where all of them are,” Lehmkuhl said. “I’m hoping to learn just that as people start nominating them!”

At the Vegan Cheesesteak Party and Cabaret, set for April 14 at the Rotunda in West Philly, local chefs’ best efforts at translating this city’s most famed dish into plant-based form will face off for a chance to be crowned king.

Helping run the show will be none other than Frank Olivieri, third-generation owner of Pat’s King of Steaks, in his third stint as emcee. He may be scion of the family credited with inventing the original meat bomb of a meal, but he’s fully on board with the idea of a vegan version.

“I am honored to once again host the vegan cheesesteak contest,” Olivieri said with a wink. “Hopefully they won’t burn me at the ‘steak.'”

Lehmkuhl, who for years wrote the “V for Veg” column in the Daily News, said there’s much less blowback from carnivores these days: “Meat-eaters are slowly becoming resigned, I’d say, to the existence of vegan cheesesteaks.”

As the sometimes heated, angry responses to a recent Billy Penn roundup of salmon cheesesteaks showed, there’s still plenty of hostility out there. Some Philadelphians feel that if it doesn’t have beef, it doesn’t deserve the moniker.

But variations are plentiful even within the canonical realm, Lehmkuhl notes.

“South Philly guys already like to argue the finer points of whether the steak should be thin-sliced or chopped, or whether the cheese is limited to American and Provolone,” he said. “If you think a vegan cheesesteak isn’t a true cheesesteak you’re perfectly free not to have one — just as you’re free to avoid Swiss like the plague.

“We’re simply trying to extend it so that everybody can enjoy Philly’s signature sandwich,” he added.

People who’ll be happy about that extension include one Dr. Michael Greger, author of NYT bestseller How Not to Die. Greger will be a judge at the April event — and the opportunity to evaluate the city’s vegan cheesesteak offerings might even have had something to do with his move to Philly.

The force behind nutritionfacts.org, Greger recently announced he planned to relocate away from D.C., and put the call out on social media for suggestions where to go. Lehmkuhl pitched Philly, promising that if Greger agree to land here he could be on the panel. “Well, a couple weeks later he called back and said he was on his way! That HAS to have been the decisive factor!” Lehmkuhl said. “There’s no other explanation, right?”

Also helping decide the winner will be:

Kaplan, who has meatlessly tickled the fancy of viewers of the Tonight Show and Netflix and Comedy Central specials, will first helm the judging table, then move on to headlining the cabaret part of the evening of plant-based fun.

After all the vegan cheesesteak samples are devoured and judging has resolved, Kaplan will treat the audience to a standup routine, and share the stage with various other performers.

First things first: the nominations to get into the competition open Friday, March 8. (Interested parties can email Lehmkuhl for more info.) Then there’s a public voting period from March 29 to April 8.

Tickets to the main event are already on sale, however — and there’s only 100 up for grabs. Save your spot here.

Mornings are for coffee and local news

Billy Penn’s free morning newsletter gives you a daily roundup of the top Philly stories you need to start your day.

You finished another Billy Penn article — keep it up!

We hope you found it useful, fun, or maybe even both. If you want more stories like this, will you join us as a member today?

Nice to see you (instead of a paywall)

Billy Penn’s mission is to provide free, quality information to Philadelphians through our articles and daily newsletter. If you believe local journalism is key to a healthy community, join us!

Your donation brought this story to life

Billy Penn only exists because of supporters like you. If you find our work valuable, consider making a sustaining donation today.

Being informed looks good on you

Thanks for reading another article, made possible by members like you. Want to share BP with a friend?