Night Kitchen Bakery's 'Pride and Prejudice' cake was one of its first large orders in a year

๐Ÿ’Œ Love Philly? Sign up for the free Billy Penn email newsletter to get everything you need to know about Philadelphia, every day.


After a year with few special occasion orders, Night Kitchen Bakery owner Amy Edelman and her staff were almost giddy when the request came in.

A customer looking to surprise his wife on her 40th birthday was ordering one of the Chestnut Hill bakeshopโ€™s signature sculptured sugar creations. Despite inviting just six people to the party where it would be revealed, he wanted it to be a showstopper.

โ€œMost of the custom and wedding cake business that we would normally have over a year was near nonexistent,โ€ Edelman said. In this case, she explained, โ€œThey couldnโ€™t have a grand party, so he ordered a grand cake.โ€

Based on โ€œPride and Prejudice,โ€ of which the recipient is apparently a huge fan, the resulting dessert turned out large enough to feed 30 people.

Fashioned by pastry chef Jackie Swain, a 15-inch chocolate mocha cake formed the shape of the Jane Austen book, with marbled swirls and lettering from a special-edition cover iced across the top. Beside it was a fondant rendition of Pemberley Mansion, its two-and-a-half-foot facade etched with columns and detailed stonework.

Figurines placed on top, based on the movie version starring Colin Firth and Jennifer Ehle, were also edible. Wording along the โ€œlawnโ€ spelled out the birthday message: โ€œYou are a timeless classic.โ€

Pastry chef Jackie Swain and her creation Credit: Courtesy Amy Edelman

The early March order turned out to be a sign of things to come, with businesses finally starting to pick back up for Night Kitchen, Edelman said. โ€œThe beautiful spring weather is bringing people out in droves.โ€

Like many food and drink entrepreneurs, sheโ€™s carefully hopeful as the city and region ramp up vaccinations and edge closer to reopening.

Twelve months ago, the situation was โ€œscary,โ€ Edelman said. Her store, which has operated on Germantown Avenue for more than 30 years, saw sales drop by 75% when walk-in service shut down and all wedding cake pre-orders were canceled. A PPP loan was a lifesaver, along with a customer-supported GoFundMe for out-of-work employees, and a slew of gift card purchases.

At Night Kitchen, business came back in waves, Edelman said. Holidays like Easter, Passover and Motherโ€™s Day were stronger than she expected. In June, when the city allowed it, she rehired all her staff. They tried out same-day ordering with curbside pickup, then pulled back when it became obvious the complexity wasnโ€™t worth the effort.

All staff members have gotten at least one shot, but theyโ€™re all still wearing masks in the small, tight, hot kitchen. While creating the โ€œPride and Prejudiceโ€ cake wasnโ€™t easy, it was an encouraging sign.

โ€œWe got through it, and business is returning,โ€ Edelman said. โ€œI am looking forward to hugging many of my customers [and] going out to eat again with my friends!โ€

Danya Henninger was first editor and then editor/director of Billy Penn at WHYY from 2018 to 2023.