Philly food and drink scene

Philadelphia’s ‘pastelillo lady’ brings a Puerto Rican favorite to pop-ups around the city

Amaryllis Rivera-Nassar relies on memory instead of recipes to create her delicious turnovers.

Courtesy Amy's Pastelillos
Philadelphia, PA - January 4, 2022: Portraits of Alisha Miranda, food and travel writer in the dining room at Messina Social Club in South Philly.

Photo by Clay Williams.

© Clay Williams /

💌 Love Philly? Sign up for the free Billy Penn newsletter to get everything you need to know about Philadelphia, every day.

Amaryllis Rivera-Nassar has become the unofficial “pastelillo lady” of Philadelphia.

Her Fishtown-based pop-up, Amy’s Pastelillos, was born from the desire to experiment with flavors for the traditional Puerto Rican turnovers. The small hand pies — which can be filled with savory ingredients like beef with peppers and onions, or sweet combinations like guava and queso — are fried till crispy golden brown, and usually eaten on the go.

“Pastelillos have always been part of my life,” Rivera-Nassar said.

The Philly native and mother of two is a former events marketer and currently works part-time booking food vendors for Garage bar. But she always felt called to the kitchen, she said, recalling how her late mother would “cook for the masses.”

Rivera-Nassar, who goes by Amy, doesn’t have formal recipes documented or passed down — which is common among Hispanic and Latinx families. So she challenged herself to recreate dishes through “smell, nostalgia and memory.”

One bite of her pastelillos will immediately stir up childhood memories for Boricuas who grew up traveling to and from the motherland.

The ground beef picadillo, an Amy’s best-seller, is juicy, peppery, and rich from the slow thickening of cubed potatoes mixed with a sofrito-layered sauce. The shredded chicken puts others to shame, with tender thigh meat stewed in its own broth and heightened by sweet notes from yellow peppers. The sleeper hit is the guava BBQ pork, a not-so-traditional tangy flavor combo that’s unexpectedly pleasing.

“People connect to these flavors, especially when they haven’t been to ‘la isla’ in a while,” Rivera-Nassar said, adding that customers are often inspired to share back their own food memories.

With a growing interest among her neighbors and much encouragement from her husband, she began selling pastelillos in November 2018, starting first at Garage Fishtown, which later led to her gig as a booker.

The operation scaled slowly, eventually establishing a rotation that included community outposts like Herman’s Coffee in Pennsport, the Sisterly Love Food Fair, events held as part of the Philadelphia Latino Film Fest, and regular showings at Riverwards Produce, where the pop-up returns on Sunday, July 11.

Rivera-Nassar aims not only to honor her mom’s cooking, but to carve out space for Puerto Rican food representation. Philadelphia has one of the largest Puerto Rican communities, second only to New York among big U.S. mainland cities, but many residents struggle to feel seen.

“We are such a big population here but no one knows about us,” Rivera-Nassar said.

Through Amy’s Pastelillos, she has a platform to educate and stoke interest in the culture. Her newest venture, GUSTO Philly, is an event series she co-founded to partner with and learn from other food makers across the diaspora, with regular spotlights that put knowledge-sharing at the forefront.

It’s paying off. At less than $5 per pastelillo, customers often buy two or three, Rivera-Nassar said, and many buy them frozen to later cook at home. Her inventory has grown to an average of 350 pastelillos at a time, with up to seven flavor options. She recently introduced wholesale options through Queen and Rook, a cafe in South Philadelphia. She credits her pastelillos’ success to how easy they are to cook, along with their versatility, affordability, and shelf-life.

Embracing an unknown future, she continues to stretch her footprint, visiting Puerto Rico twice a year. She tastes tons of food — for “research,” of course — and also is “exploring new urban farming and how our food culture is changing.”

For Rivera-Nassar, the success of Amy’s Pastelillos is a testament that Philadelphians are ready to enjoy a varied food culture, and that one-woman shops like hers are just one way to keep traditions alive.

Follow her on Instagram to find where to grab a bite at a future pop-up near you.

Want some more? Explore other Philly food and drink scene stories.

Mornings are for coffee and local news

Billy Penn’s free morning newsletter gives you a daily roundup of the top Philly stories you need to start your day.

You finished another Billy Penn article — keep it up!

We hope you found it useful, fun, or maybe even both. If you want more stories like this, will you join us as a member today?

Nice to see you (instead of a paywall)

Billy Penn’s mission is to provide free, quality information to Philadelphians through our articles and daily newsletter. If you believe local journalism is key to a healthy community, join us!

Your donation brought this story to life

Billy Penn only exists because of supporters like you. If you find our work valuable, consider making a sustaining donation today.

Being informed looks good on you

Thanks for reading another article, made possible by members like you. Want to share BP with a friend?